Brian Jepson’s Weblog

Originally posted on the BIF Speak blog.

Walt Mossberg continued his conversations on day 2 of BIF-3, bringing storyteller Clayton Christensen up on stage. It was refreshing to see Christensen say that the cell phone is poised to disrupt the personal computer because I’m a firm believer in that, too. What was really fun for me was the conversation about Nokia vs. Apple. If you’ve gotten a coffee or a beer in me, you’ve probably heard me rant on and on about this, but never as articulate as Christensen and Mossberg. Now you’re all in trouble, because I think I can speak more lucidly and loudly about this.

Christensen said his money is on Nokia to build a platform that disrupts the personal computer. Mossberg replied that Nokia has made several tries to do this, and they all sucked. I completely agree with Christensen, and even with Mossberg (who, for the record, made it clear he wasn’t placing bets). I have two phones in my pocket at all times: a Nokia 6290 and an Apple iPhone. When geeks ask me which cell phone they should buy, I give them a rundown on the issues and a little demo. The first thing I tell them is that if they are a geek and love tinkering with things and hacking them to do stuff that they won’t do out of the box, get a Nokia phone (but don’t get the 6290; I got it because it was the cheapest phone I could find running the latest version of the webkit browser). Then I tell them that both platforms use the same wonderful web browser, WebKit, which is the engine that powers both Safari and the S60 Browser.

There’s no question that the iPhone is a powerful product, and it’s going to get better. But my money’s on Nokia, too, for pretty much the same reasons Christensen has. Christensen said that the iPhone is a sustaining innovation: it keeps the iTunes Music Store platform alive in the face of more and more cellular companies competing with Apple on music downloads. But if you pick up a high end Nokia phone today and spend time tinkering with it… I mean really spend the time: download some of the 3rd-party software for it, mess around with Nokia’s Python interpreter, tweak every setting, and maybe even look at the free SDK and write a Hello, World. What I think you’ll see is a simmering cauldron of disruptive innovation, with a not-so-pretty user interface.

If this doesn’t sound familiar to you, let me jog your memory. What is Mac OS X? It’s a simmering cauldron of not-so-pretty disruptive innovation: FreeBSD, NetBSD, Linux, the GNU Compiler Collection, the Apache web server, and much more. What Apple did was take a beautiful user interface (NEXTSTEP), make it even better, and put it on top of that mess. What happens when Nokia takes that crucial step?

update: I spoke with Walt Mossberg during the break, and he made an important point. It’s wrong to look at Mac OS X as just a pretty face on top of a mess of random bits, and what I wrote above frames it that way. The NEXTSTEP-derived bits that make Mac OS X so wonderful are a really thick part of the whole stack. And likewise, it would be wrong to look at Nokia’s Series 60 as just a mess of disjoint components; it has many usable bits, particular the S60 web browser, high on up the stack. Nokia still has a lot of work ahead of it. If I were them, I’d stop with the feature set they have now, and spend all my resources on making a user interface as good or better than the iPhone. This doesn’t mean changing their icons or rearranging the layout of controls. They need to refactor things in such a way that usability permeates the Series 60 operating system.

At first, it seemed incredible that a bug like this could find its way into a shipping product, and it becomes even more annoying when you realize you probably won’t see a fix for it until you buy another phone. But there’s probably a simple explanation for it, and the fact is, everything works fine for a lot of people (but I’m going to stop just short of apologizing for Microsoft, because it’s annoying the hell out of me).

The problem is this: when you delete items from certain IMAP servers, they don’t stay deleted. My guess is that this is common on IMAP servers like the one I use, where everything is organized under one top-level folder (INBOX, in my case). When the Smartphone’s Pocket Inbox goes to create Deleted Items (or whatever folder it wants) in the root of my IMAP space, it fails and so does the delete.

So, there’s a simple workaround: use the move option (right menu, 5) to move it to your trash folder (in my case, INBOX.Trash), and then do a sync (right menu, 9). I have a feeling this problem would go away if I could tell Pocket Inbox to use INBOX as the top-level IMAP folder, though.

Dave is doing some cool stuff with mobile blogging, not to mention mobile blog reading. This is my first post from his newly-launched YoMoBlog.com. Dave says it’s short for Your Mobile Weblog, but I think it’s short for Yo! Moblog!

A few months ago, my home state made the news for its work on an initiative to cover the state in wireless with a true border-to-border network. The RI-WINS initiative (Rhode Island Wireless Innovation Networks) officially flipped the switch on June 19th, and I had the honor of organizing and moderating a Providence Geeks Town Hall event where the RI-WINS folks explained the project and answered some questions about it. Some of the interesting tidbits:

• It will take 120 WiMAX base stations to cover Rhode Island.
• Initially, the network will not target end-users, but…
• …there is one RI community that is talking with RI-WINS about providing access to people who can’t afford broadband

Find out more in the event coverage: Part I and Part II.

I’ve been organizing a Town Hall-style event for Providence Geeks. It goes down next week: Wednesday June 21 at AS220, from 5pm to 6pm. Representatives of the RI-WINS project will be on hand to brief people on this effort, and will be taking questions from the public. It’s open to the public, so come on down and find out what’s going to be happening in a 5GHz channel near you!

If you’re going out to the Maker Faire, be sure to drop by the Hacks booth and say howdy. I’ll be bringing some goodies related to a few of our hacks books, and there will be plenty of toys you can mess around with.

I’ll be giving a short talk and demonstration on Ubuntu Hacks today (Wednesday, April 5 at 12:30) at the O’Reilly LinuxWorld booth. Drop by and learn about getting Ubuntu running under colinux, going online with a Bluetooth connection and a cell phone, and a few more things.

This is weird. I’m in Providence, connected to the Internet via T-Mobile EDGE (PowerBook to Treo via Bluetooth) and everything works just fine… except anything at google.com (including gmail.com). http://www.google.com/pda is the only google property that works. What’s stranger is that I can access these sites from my Treo’s browser fine, just not from any browser on my computer. I’m not the only one, and this has been going on for a long time. Yahoo works just fine, though. I wonder if there’s an easy way to load my gmail archive into Yahoo! mail?

gnat: “Apparently the infrastructure whose costs they’re
recouping is entirely built out of fibre spun from the eyelashes of
Indonesian princesses and each packet is transmitted in a 24 karat solid
gold envelope.”

As soon as I
was sure I had EDGE speeds in 02881, I snagged a GC82
EDGE card on eBay for around $50. It arrived today, and I’ve told
the story of its setup in
pictures.